Skip to main content

Joker of Cakes

It all began last week -- the day I wanted to eat my words. I said to Ryan, "For your birthday I will make you any cake you want! The options are limitless!"


I should've known better. Ryan is always up for challenge. My original thoughts that his request would be something benign like chocolate cake, vanilla or marble cake, maybe ever carrot cake.

He got a big grin on his face, and said "I would like  an Ice cream cake."



Simple enough, right? Oh no. This was different than the ice cream cake I've always known.

I could just see the excitement building in his eyes. And he then goes on....:

 "Not just any ice cream cake. I want the cake part to be white. No, I take that back - I want it to be marble. Not yellow and chocolate. White and chocolate. Then I went the ice cream to be............cookies & cream. Oo! And then garnished with hot fudge."



I took the challenge head-on. I thought, "Hey I can do this!"

Then he goes on, "Oh, and the frosting? I want it to be orange. That way you have to figure out how to mix the colors."  (Jokingly, obviously. Anyone can figure out their primary colors to make orange....)


So I consulted my Betty Crocker cookbook, I consulted allrecipes.com, I consulted my trusty Mom. And formed a "Plan of Attack". For, let's just clarify - I don't do well with desserts. I'm more of a bread-baking, meat-marinating, side-dish cookin' kind-of-gal.

The instructions seemed.....fricking impossible challenging. But, I tried. And here is how it played out:

  • So 1st step came baking the cake. I did a 9 x 13 inch Marble Cake. It filled the house with glorious smells, and looked wonderful! Hurray! I'm a pro.
  • Let cool overnight. (all is well, still. I woke up in the morning, and the cake was cool. Still a pro)
  • Cut 9 x 13 cake in half. (Score!)
  • Remove cakes from pan.
  • ..........................
  • This is easier said than done, in my world of baking. They weren't neccessarily stuck, they just didn't want to come out.
  • So I flipped it upside down on my board.
  • Nothing.
  • So I shook it a little.
  • Still nothing.
  • I proceeded to flip it over, shake it, beat it with my hands, pound the hell out of the cake.
  • Still nothing.
  • So, I got out multiple knives, spatulas, etc and decided to pry it out.
  • Cake came out, but.......had some crumbles. (No biggy! Frosting=glue)
  • Now time to make the frosting. I made a "White Mountain Frosting" so it had the peaks and was very soft and wonderful. I even used a candy thermometer (My 1st time ever) It turned out wonderful.
  • Now, it was time to make it orange.............
  • I read the package instructions.....I figured out I didn't have normal food coloring. It was neon.
  • I read "8 drops pink, 3 drops green"
  • So I proceeded.
  • However, orange was not the color I was seeing. So I added more pink and more green.
  • It just kept getting darker and more vibrant of this god-awful pinkish, orangish, flesh-ish color.
  • So I looked at the directions again.
  • Oops! I was using purple and green, not pink and green.
  • So I started adding pink.
  • It only got worse - Ryan's Frosting is Human-Flesh Colored. Nice.
  • Well, the damage had been done. And there's no way I was starting over again.
  • I proceeded to frost the cake a nice "fleshy" color.
  • Then it was time to do the ice cream layer. I scooped on the ice-cream, and it layed out quite nice.
  • Now it was time for Layer # 2 of the cake.
  • This was difficult, and took me a long time.
  • By the time I got the cake on top of the ice-cream; must icecream had melted.
  • So I popped it in the freezer. Came back to check in an hour and....
  • Ice cream refroze and expanded everywhere!!! Ice cream was eating my ugly fleshy cake.
  • I cut off the excess, and made it look managable pretty. All will be...manageable
Now lets take you to Wednesday night, time to light the candles and for me to solely sing Happy Birthday to Ryan. (poor guy....)

We decided to just do one candle (kind of like people choose to do when they get old and gray and have so many candles it may be a fire hazard.......) I didn't want the ice cream to melt.

And here is the finished product (brace yourselves, folks)


I let Ryan do the honors of cutting into the cake. I was expecting to see 3 gorgeous layers - perfectly froze out.

And we come to find........

No ice cream?!!?!

Yep, apparently when it melted out, I cut it off - and the other remainder of ice cream melted into the cake layers.

It was like a magic trick. I made a layer of cake disappear!

In the end, it tasted really good. The cake was nice and moist and did have an ice-cream flavor to it! And the fleshy frosting tasted wonderful.

Let's just say.....Ace of Cakes won't be recruiting me anytime soon. And I don't think Ryan will ever request soemthing "outside the norm" for a birthday cake again!

Comments

oh my god, I am laughing out loud at work. Like, I am dieing of laughter here. this is probably the funniest post you have ever written. hilarious.

Can I jsut say - you are one hell of a wife.
Marlys said…
I loved the pictures in the post! Great job! I've been waiting patiently for the picture and it looks like you said it would! I have some suggestions! When you need to remove a cake from the pan, you should line it with greased wax paper and then it will just pop out! Also, I think if you had frozen the cake after you cut it in half, the ice cream wouldn't have melted so fast! Other than that, I think you did a great job and you will never forget the first cake you made for your hubby!
Cherry Blossoms said…
I am sitting here laughing out loud as well. Oh Abby you kill me. What a great memory for you guys!
Jess said…
This really was hilarious!! In my opinion, he'd be crazy to ask for anything but a cake out of the norm..just for the story that can come out of the making of it. I'm really impressed at your hard work and determination though, gotta say.
Unknown said…
Now that is love!

Popular posts from this blog

What is your color?

Green My favorite color ever! I have to control myself to not purchase too many green things. If I had no control, my house would be green. My kitchen would be lime-themed. With greenery everywhere. My bathrooms would be green. My bedroom would be green. You would all feel nauseated-green after entering my home. (So I don't have a green-themed home) Many things I love are green, such as: Spinach (I eat it a minimum twice a day usually) My weding color was green. (clover green) Limes (I have at least one time a day) Grass. I love the feel of grass, especially since I see it so rarely in AZ (except in my neighborhood that has amazing landscapers with grass-galore) Palm trees. Any tree. Christmas trees. I love Christmas Green Beer. I think the green beer on St. Patty's Day tastes better. My favorite color of eyes. When I was in 9th grade, I so badly wanted to get green contacts. But they made me keep my brown eyes. Diet Mountain Dew (my guilty pleasure) Granny Smith

Currently - May edition

   I haven't blogged much - but the last time I did one of these, Maddy was 9 months old. It's really fun looking back on the things that were "stressors" to me at that time. Prior to that - my currently post was a pregnancy edition.  So here goes May 2022. Maddy is almost a 15-month old and summer has set ablaze here in Tucson.   Reading :  I really wish I had a better answer for this one, but I have not been the best about reading lately. The only book I'm reading is "How to talk to your kids so they'll listen and listen so they'll talk". It is really good. Most of the book is geared more to school-aged kids, in my opinion. But it highlights some great communication skills with children to help them trust you as a parent to be open and honest. Eating: All the smoothies. It has been getting really hot here - and every day when we get home from our stroller run I make a smoothie for Maddy with whole milk, Fage, and fruit - and then a smoothie for

8 Months

 Well, I missed month 1-8. But it is never too late to begin, right? Here is a recap of Maddy at 8 months. (I'm totally stealing this idea from my sister, Lisa. I thought it was so neat that she recaps her son's favorites and happenings every month)   How am I sleeping? Better than I was - but not as good as my peers. It also depends on if I'm teething. Last week, her 2nd tooth was poking through - so she was awake 3 times.  No matter how much I let her cry it out, I cannot seem to cut down her feedings. When I go in there - she is literally pulling at my shirt with her mouth wide open. So clearly she's hungry.  She eats 2 times/night and luckily goes right back to sleep. It is what it is. What am I eating? While we have had breastfeeding and bottle refusal struggles - I am so glad that taking to food as been relatively smooth. We are doing baby led weaning, and Maddy really enjoys most every food I've given her.  Her favorite foods are scrambled eggs, apples, and c